I like this tip I found in this month’s Cosmo:

Skimp on makeup remover. "Johnson’s Baby Shampoo with No More Tears formula is a great, gentle way to take off your eye makeup. A big bottle costs less and lasts much longer than tiny bottles of actual eye-makeup remover." - Kimara Ahnert (11/08, pg. 211)

Makes perfect sense! I hate the idea of spending money on an eye makeup remover - I don’t wear enough of it on a regular basis to justify the expense. But when I do need it, I always curse that I don’t have any. Having a bottle of baby shampoo around to both gently wash my hair and to remove heavy eye makeup sounds like win-win.